Evidence record

Medicaid Managed Care Behavioral Health Service Denials in Philadelphia by Community Behavioral Health

Jurisdiction
Pennsylvania
Audit organization
Office of Inspector General, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
Publication date
June 2026
Source record
Original document linked
Open original reportOriginal source available

Findings

5

Recommendations

6

Overall conclusion

CBH did not comply with Federal and State requirements for denying prior-authorization behavioral health services; none of the 100 sampled denials complied with all applicable requirements, indicating potential systemic issues in denials and potential impact on enrollee rights.

Scope

Audit period January 1, 2023 through December 31, 2023; CBH denied 1,102 prior authorization requests; Philadelphia; random sample of 100 denials reviewed to assess compliance with Federal and State requirements.

Findings (5)

Each finding has a stable link.

  1. F-1241

    CBH did not comply with address-change notification procedures and sent denial notices to incorrect addresses (17 denied service requests).

  2. F-1242

    CBH did not provide timely notification that a request was denied (1 denied service request).

  3. F-1243

    CBH did not inform enrollees of their right to access all relevant documents free of charge (all 100 denied service requests).

  4. F-1244

    CBH issued denial notices that did not clearly explain the adverse benefit determinations (14 denied service requests).

  5. F-1245

    CBH did not document the extra steps it took to request that the enrollee’s representative contact the provider before CBH denied services for enrollees under 21 (34 denied service requests).

Recommendations (6)

  1. R-1097

    Update CBH policies and procedures to reconcile address discrepancies between addresses of record and addresses given to treatment providers and implement a process to determine residency changes and notify the County Assistance Office accordingly.

    Related finding F-1241
  2. R-1098

    Implement a process for identifying service requests that are considered approved because a decision notification was not sent within the 21-day window.

    Related finding F-1242
  3. R-1099

    Coordinate with the State agency to implement a revised initial denial notice informing enrollees of their right to access all documents, records, and other information relevant to the adverse benefit determination, free of charge, as required by 42 CFR 438.404(b)(2).

    Related finding F-1243
  4. R-1100

    Revise the denial notice language to clarify when services are denied as requested but alternative services not requiring prior authorization are recommended, as opposed to an outright denial with no alternatives.

    Related finding F-1244
  5. R-1101

    Update CBH policies to require staff to document steps taken to contact the enrollee’s representative to request that the representative ask the provider to communicate with CBH, and efforts to reach the provider before denial notices for enrollees under 21.

    Related finding F-1245
  6. R-1102

    State agency: Revise the HealthChoices denial notice template to include a statement that the enrollee has the right to receive, upon request and at no charge, all documents and records relevant to the adverse determination.

    Related finding F-1243