Evidence record
Medicaid Program – Oversight of Health Homes
- Jurisdiction
- New York
- Publishing agency
- Office of the New York State Comptroller, Division of State Government Accountability
- Publication date
- January 20, 2026
- Source record
- Original document linked
Findings
4
Recommendations
7
Overall conclusion
DOH did not adequately oversee Medicaid Health Homes to ensure appropriate care and payments, including delays in redesignation reviews, noncompliance with policies, and lack of baseline measurements, with $19.7 million in payments lacking proper MAPP-based support; the agency has since implemented improvements to redesignation processes and related controls.
Scope
January 2019 through June 2023, with analysis of selected performance measures through March 2024 and review of the redesignation process through October 2024.
Findings (4)
Each finding has a stable link.
- F-1297
DOH did not adequately oversee Medicaid Health Homes to ensure appropriate care and payments, including not completing redesignation reviews for all Health Homes within the required time frames and inconsistent monitoring prior to August 2023 when improvements were implemented.
- F-1298
Health Homes frequently did not comply with Medicaid policies and procedures, such as updating members’ care plans when needed.
- F-1299
Performance measure calculations did not include baseline measurements, hindering evaluation of progress and program effectiveness.
- F-1300
From January 2019 through June 2023, auditors identified $19.7 million in payments across 67,026 claims that lacked proper support in the MAPP System.
Recommendations (7)
- R-1145
Ensure redesignation reviews are conducted timely in accordance with the redesignation policy.
Related finding F-1297 - R-1146
Formally evaluate whether the redesignation process should be improved to ensure that Health Homes (via the plan of care and other actions) are addressing the underlying risk factors members were identified to have upon enrollment in the Health Home program.
Related finding F-1297 - R-1147
Ensure that Health Homes submit Enhanced Oversight Plans timely, when required, and with adequate detail.
Related finding F-1297 - R-1148
Formally evaluate whether to include baseline data calculations (such as Health Home member circumstances before enrollment) in the Health Home performance measures to: More accurately score Domain 2 of Health Home redesignation reviews, and Effectively measure the overall performance of the Program.
Related finding F-1299 - R-1149
Review the $19.7 million in payments that lacked proper support in the MAPP System attestations, and make recoveries, as appropriate.
Related finding F-1300 - R-1150
Ensure that Health Home claims are properly supported in the MAPP System and make recoveries on improper payments, as appropriate.
Related finding F-1300 - R-1151
Ensure the MCO identified in this report takes corrective actions to prevent erroneously paying voided Health Home claims due to retroactive rate changes.