Evidence record

Public Assistance Reporting Information System Alerts

Jurisdiction
Ohio
Publishing agency
Ohio Auditor of State
Audit organization
Auditor of State of Ohio
Publication date
December 13, 2022
Source record
Original document linked
Open original reportOriginal source available

Findings

8

Recommendations

4

Overall conclusion

Based on the sampling results, 59% of PARIS alerts were not worked or not worked timely; this undermines the effectiveness of PARIS in controlling improper capitation payments. The Department’s corrective actions and monitoring efforts are ongoing, and the audit results support the recommendations.

Scope

PARIS alerts generated in June, September, and December 2021. Sample of 330 alerts across three counties (Cuyahoga, Franklin, Summit). Review of Ohio Benefits, MITS, verification letters, residency determinations, and capitation payments for improper payments.

Findings (8)

Each finding has a stable link.

  1. F-1200

    CDJFS caseworkers did not work a substantial portion of the PARIS alerts, which has a significant impact on Ohio’s Medicaid program.

  2. F-1201

    Not working and not timely working PARIS alerts could have a potential impact on the Ohio Medicaid program between $5.3 million and $24.5 million.

  3. F-1202

    Of the 330 sampled PARIS alerts, 194 contained errors (59% error rate): 158 alerts not worked at all and 36 not worked timely.

  4. F-1203

    There were 13 instances where the alert was worked but not within the required timeframe and the recipient was determined to be a non-Ohio resident; identified over $16,091 in improper capitation payments.

  5. F-1204

    For 199 of the 330 sampled alerts (60%), no initial verification letter was sent by the CDJFS and an additional six instances where a subsequent verification letter was not sent.

  6. F-1205

    Finding for Recovery: $16,091.

  7. F-1206

    The results indicate that 59% of PARIS alerts were not worked or not worked timely; this supports ongoing concerns about the PARIS process.

  8. F-1207

    The Department identified recommendations to improve the PARIS alert process including monitoring, training, updating guides, and reviewing sampled alerts for possible recoupments.

Recommendations (4)

  1. R-1071

    Evaluate Current PARIS Alert Process and the Ohio Benefits System: evaluate enhancements, obtain CDJFS input, consider adding due dates and automate verification letters, address repeated alerts and the heavy county workload.

    Related finding F-1200
  2. R-1072

    Monitoring and Technical Assistance: follow the monitoring plan monthly, provide assistance to counties for processing PARIS alerts.

    Related finding F-1206
  3. R-1073

    PARIS Alert Processing Guide and Training: update the PARIS Alert Processing Guide and hold annual PARIS alert training.

    Related finding F-1204
  4. R-1074

    Review the Sampled PARIS Alerts: review non-worked alerts to verify residency and recoup any capitation payments where appropriate.

    Related finding F-1203